Overview
The Earth Grid Design calculator performs substation earthing grid analysis per IEEE Std 80 — Guide for Safety in AC Substation Grounding. It sizes a rectangular buried conductor grid with optional ground rods and verifies that touch and step voltages remain within safe limits during ground faults.
The calculator provides:
- Grid resistance — IEEE 80-2013 Eq. 57 (Sverak)
- Ground Potential Rise (GPR) — If × Rg
- Mesh (touch) voltage — Em within the grid mesh
- Step voltage — Es at the grid perimeter
- Tolerable voltage limits — for 50 kg or 70 kg body weight with surface layer
- Safety assessment — PASS if Em ≤ Etouch AND Es ≤ Estep
- Grid conductor sizing — minimum CSA by IEEE 80-2013 Eq. 37 with the Table 1 constants of the conductor material
For complex non-rectangular grids or 3D visualization, use the Earth Grid 3D Tool in the Tools menu.
Input Parameters
Grid Geometry
| Parameter | Default | Range | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
grid_length | 60 m | 1 – 500 | Grid length (X direction) |
grid_width | 40 m | 1 – 500 | Grid width (Y direction) |
spacing | 6 m | 1 – 50 | Conductor spacing in both directions |
burial_depth | 0.5 m | 0.3 – 2.0 | Burial depth below ground surface |
Conductor
| Parameter | Default | Description |
|---|---|---|
conductor_diameter | 12.78 mm | Conductor diameter (≈120 mm² Cu) |
conductor_material | Cu_annealed | IEEE 80 Table 1 material: Cu_annealed, Cu_hard_drawn, Cu_clad_steel (40 %), Cu_clad_steel_30, Al_clad_steel, Steel_1020, Stainless_clad_steel, Steel_galvanized (zinc-coated steel rod), Stainless_304 |
ambient_temperature | 40 °C | Ta in Eq. 37 (−40 – 60) |
joint_type | bolted | Grid connection type setting Tm in Eq. 37 = min(joint limit, material fusing temperature): exothermic_weld (fusing temperature), brazed (450 °C), bolted (250 °C; bolted, clamp and compression / pressure-type connectors). See the joint table under Formulas. |
max_conductor_temperature | none (from joint type) | Explicit Tm override (100 – 1510 °C, above the ambient and not above the material's fusing temperature), e.g. a connector qualified to IEEE Std 837 for a higher temperature. When given it replaces the joint limit. |
Ground Rods
| Parameter | Default | Description |
|---|---|---|
num_rods | 20 | Number of vertical ground rods |
rod_length | 3 m | Length of each rod |
rod_diameter | 16 mm | Rod diameter (documentation only — not used by Eq. 57 or the mesh/step equations) |
Fault & Soil Parameters
| Parameter | Default | Description |
|---|---|---|
soil_resistivity | 100 Ω·m | Soil resistivity (1 – 10,000) |
fault_current | 10 kA | Maximum grid fault current |
clearing_time | 0.5 s | Fault clearing time (0.01 – 3) |
Safety Criteria
| Parameter | Default | Description |
|---|---|---|
body_weight | 70 kg | Body weight for tolerable voltage (50 or 70 kg) |
surface_resistivity | 3,000 Ω·m | Surface layer resistivity (e.g. crushed rock) |
surface_thickness | 0.1 m | Surface layer thickness |
Output Results
| Output | Symbol | Unit | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grid Resistance | Rg | Ω | Total grid-to-earth resistance |
| GPR | GPR | V | Ground Potential Rise = If × Rg |
| Mesh Voltage | Em | V | Maximum touch voltage within grid mesh |
| Step Voltage | Es | V | Maximum step voltage at grid perimeter |
| Tolerable Touch | Etouch | V | Maximum safe touch voltage for body weight |
| Tolerable Step | Estep | V | Maximum safe step voltage for body weight |
| Touch Safe | — | PASS / FAIL | Em ≤ Etouch |
| Step Safe | — | PASS / FAIL | Es ≤ Estep |
| Overall | — | PASS / FAIL | Both touch and step must pass |
| Joint type and Tm used | Tm | °C | Connection type and the maximum conductor temperature used in Eq. 37, with its basis (joint limit, fusing temperature or override) |
| Grid conductor k | k | A·√s/mm² | Equivalent constant from Eq. 37 and Table 1 |
| Grid conductor minimum / selected | A | mm² | Eq. 37 minimum and next standard size |
Formulas
Grid Resistance — IEEE 80-2013 Eq. 57 (Sverak)
Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))]
Where A = L × W (grid area), LT = total buried conductor length (grid + rods), h = burial depth (valid for 0.25 – 2.5 m). The depth correction multiplies the area term only; the 1/LT term is not depth-corrected.
Grid Conductor Size — IEEE 80-2013 Eq. 37
Amm² = IkA / √[ (TCAP × 10-4 / (tc αr ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta)) ]
= I √tc / k, k = 1000 √[ (TCAP × 10-4 / (αr ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta)) ]
Material constants (IEEE 80-2013 Table 1). The last column, the Eq. 41 constant Kf for Tm = fusing temperature and Ta = 40 °C, is reproduced by the other constants and is shown as a check; k is the resulting A·√s/mm² value at those temperatures.
| Material | Conductivity (%) | αr at 20 °C (1/°C) | K0 (°C) | Fusing Tm (°C) | ρr at 20 °C (µΩ·cm) | TCAP (J/(cm³·°C)) | Kf | k (40 °C, fusing) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Copper, annealed soft-drawn | 100.0 | 0.00393 | 234 | 1083 | 1.72 | 3.42 | 7.00 | 281.8 |
| Copper, commercial hard-drawn | 97.0 | 0.00381 | 242 | 1084 | 1.78 | 3.42 | 7.06 | 279.4 |
| Copper-clad steel wire | 40.0 | 0.00378 | 245 | 1084 | 4.40 | 3.85 | 10.45 | 188.8 |
| Copper-clad steel wire | 30.0 | 0.00378 | 245 | 1084 | 5.86 | 3.85 | 12.06 | 163.6 |
| Aluminium-clad steel wire | 20.3 | 0.00360 | 258 | 657 | 8.48 | 3.58 | 17.20 | 114.7 |
| Steel, 1020 | 10.8 | 0.00160 | 605 | 1510 | 15.90 | 3.28 | 15.95 | 123.7 |
| Stainless-clad steel rod | 9.8 | 0.00160 | 605 | 1400 | 17.50 | 4.44 | 14.72 | 134.1 |
| Zinc-coated steel rod | 8.6 | 0.00320 | 293 | 419 | 20.10 | 3.93 | 28.96 | 68.1 |
| Stainless steel, 304 | 2.4 | 0.00130 | 749 | 1400 | 72.00 | 4.03 | 30.05 | 65.7 |
Maximum Conductor Temperature Tm — joint type
The conductor is sized for the weakest element of the conductor and its connections, so Tm is the lower of the joint temperature limit and the material fusing temperature:
Tm = min(Tjoint, Tfusing) (or the explicit max_conductor_temperature when given)
joint_type | Connection | Tjoint (°C) | Annealed Cu, 10 kA, 0.5 s, Ta 40 °C |
|---|---|---|---|
exothermic_weld | Exothermic (thermit) weld — fuses with the conductor | fusing temperature (Table 1) | Tm 1083 °C, k 281.8, 25.09 mm² → 35 mm² |
brazed | Brazed joint | 450 | k 215.1, 32.87 mm² → 35 mm² |
bolted (default) | Bolted, clamp and compression (pressure-type) connectors | 250 | k 169.7, 41.68 mm² → 50 mm² |
Limits as tabulated by IEEE Std 80-1986 for the connecting means (pressure-type connectors 250 – 350 °C,
the lower bound used here; brazed 450 °C; exothermic weld = conductor fusing temperature) and carried into the
conductor/connection selection discussion of IEEE Std 80-2013 §11.3, which also recommends staying at or below
250 °C where hard-drawn copper must not anneal. BS 7430:2011 gives the same 450 °C brazed and 250 °C bolted
values. bolted is the default because it is the common field connection and the conservative choice.
A connector qualified to IEEE Std 837 for a higher temperature is entered with max_conductor_temperature.
Where the joint limit is above the fusing temperature (zinc-coated steel, 419 °C, with a brazed joint) the fusing
temperature governs.
Surface Layer Derating (Cs)
Cs = 1 - 0.09 × (1 - ρsoil/ρsurface) / (2hs + 0.09)
Tolerable Voltages
Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × Cs × ρs) × Cb / √t Estep = (1000 + 6 × Cs × ρs) × Cb / √t
Cb = 0.116 (50 kg) or 0.157 (70 kg).
Mesh & Step Voltages
Em = (ρ × If × Km × Ki) / (LM + LR) Es = (ρ × If × Ks × Ki) / (0.75Ls + 0.85LR)
Mesh Spacing Factor (Km) — IEEE 80 eq. 81
Km = (1/2π) × [ln(D²/(16hd) + (D+2h)²/(8Dd) - h/(4d)) + (Kii/Kh) × ln(8/(π(2n-1)))]
Where D = spacing, h = burial depth, d = conductor diameter, n = effective conductors. Kh = √(1+h), Kii = 1 (with rods) or 1/(2n)2/n (without rods).
Step Spacing Factor (Ks) — IEEE 80 eq. 83
Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2h) + 1/(D+h) + (1/D)(1 - 0.5n-2)]
Irregularity Factor (Ki) — IEEE 80 eq. 89
Ki = 0.644 + 0.148n
Worked Examples
The 18 examples below are the validation cases for this calculation. Each one was produced by the calculation engine from the inputs shown, every figure was checked against the independent reference quoted at the end of the example, and the same cases are run against every engine build (see validation scorecard, tool fe_calc_earthing; worked examples for every calculation).
| # | Case | Rg (Ω) | GPR (V) | Em / Etouch (V) | Es / Estep (V) | Tm (°C) | Conductor (mm²) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Small 20 × 20 m grid in 50 Ω·m soil, four corner rods, 1 kA | 1.260 | 1,260 | 200 / 239 | 187 / 289 | 250 | 6 | PASS |
| 2 | 60 × 40 m grid, 20 rods, crushed rock, 10 kA | 1.002 | 10,016 | 1,511 / 921 | 1,164 / 3,020 | 250 | 50 | FAIL |
| 3 | Large 100 × 80 m grid, 10 m spacing, 40 rods, 8 kA | 0.547 | 4,372 | 758 / 870 | 447 / 2,815 | 250 | 35 | PASS |
| 4 | Fine 2.5 m mesh buried 1 m, hard-drawn 8 mm copper, 70 kg | 1.671 | 6,683 | 1,082 / 1,186 | 794 / 3,882 | 250 | 16 | PASS |
| 5 | The same fine mesh assessed for a 50 kg body | 1.671 | 6,683 | 1,082 / 876 | 794 / 2,868 | 250 | 16 | FAIL |
| 6 | Copper-clad steel grid, 2 kA for 1 s | 1.833 | 3,665 | 525 / 655 | 461 / 2,150 | 1,084 | 16 | PASS |
| 7 | Galvanised steel grid, 0.2 s clearing, 5000 Ω·m rock | 3.782 | 15,127 | 2,121 / 2,216 | 1,840 / 7,811 | 419 | 35 | PASS |
| 8 | 30 × 30 m grid, 200 Ω·m, no rods, no surface layer | 3.354 | 6,708 | 1,360 / 289 | 934 / 488 | 250 | 10 | FAIL |
| 9 | Coarse 10 m mesh: touch voltage fails, step passes | 1.856 | 1,856 | 549 / 255 | 256 / 355 | 250 | 6 | FAIL |
| 10 | Rocky 1000 Ω·m site, 1 s clearing: both limits fail | 12.869 | 38,606 | 7,805 / 392 | 4,749 / 1,099 | 250 | 25 | FAIL |
| 11 | 30 % copper-clad steel with bolted joints limited to 250 °C | 1.219 | 6,093 | 854 / 921 | 747 / 3,020 | 250 | 50 | PASS |
| 12 | 1020 steel grid, 4 kA for 1 s | 1.422 | 5,689 | 604 / 655 | 697 / 2,150 | 1,510 | 35 | PASS |
| 13 | 304 stainless steel at 20 °C ambient | 1.576 | 7,879 | 924 / 1,039 | 1,158 / 3,295 | 1,400 | 50 | PASS |
| 14 | 40 × 40 m grid buried 2 m: depth term of Eq. 57 | 1.155 | 3,464 | 605 / 921 | 207 / 3,020 | 250 | 16 | PASS |
| 15 | Joint type: exothermic-welded annealed copper, 10 kA for 0.5 s | 0.782 | 7,822 | 793 / 921 | 940 / 3,020 | 1,083 | 35 | PASS |
| 16 | Joint type: brazed annealed copper (450 °C), 10 kA for 0.5 s | 0.782 | 7,822 | 793 / 921 | 940 / 3,020 | 450 | 35 | PASS |
| 17 | Joint type: bolted annealed copper (250 °C), 10 kA for 0.5 s | 0.782 | 7,822 | 793 / 921 | 940 / 3,020 | 250 | 50 | PASS |
| 18 | Tm override: IEEE 837-qualified compression connectors at 350 °C | 0.782 | 7,822 | 793 / 921 | 940 / 3,020 | 350 | 50 | PASS |
Example 1 — Small 20 × 20 m grid in 50 Ω·m soil, four corner rods, 1 kA
A compact distribution-substation grid in good soil without a surface layer: four rods set Kii = 1 and the 1 kA grid current keeps both voltages under the limits.
Given: Soil ρ = 50 Ω·m; grid current IG = 1 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 20 × 20 m, conductors at D = 4 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; 4 rods × 3 m (16 mm); no surface layer; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊20/4⌋ + 1 = 6; ny = ⌊20/4⌋ + 1 = 6; LC = 6 × 20 + 6 × 20 = 240 m; LR = 4 × 3 = 12 m; LT = 252 m; A = 20 × 20 = 400 m²; Lp = 2 × (20 + 20) = 80 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | No surface layer: ρs = ρ = 50 Ω·m, so Cs = 1.0000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 50) × 0.157/√0.5 = 238.7 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 50) × 0.157/√0.5 = 288.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 50 × [1/252 + (1/√(20 × 400)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/400)))] = 50 × [0.003968 + 0.011180 × 1.8994] = 1.2602 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 1,000 × 1.2602 = 1,260.2 V vs Etouch 238.7 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 240/80 = 6.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(80/(4 × √400)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 6.0000 × 1.0000 = 6.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(4²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (4 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 4 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 6.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(207.84) + 0.8165 × ln(0.2315)] = 0.6592 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 6.000 = 1.5320 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 50 × 1,000 × 0.6592 × 1.5320 / (240 + 12) = 200.4 V → 200.4 vs limit 238.7 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(4 + 0.5) + (1/4) × (1 − 0.56.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.2222 + 0.2344] = 0.4636 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 240 + 0.85 × 12 = 190.2 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 50 × 1,000 × 0.4636 × 1.5320 / 190.2 = 186.7 V → 186.7 vs limit 288.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 1,000 × √0.5 / 169.66 = 4.17 mm² → next standard size 6 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 84 % and step 65 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: no surface layer so ρ_s = ρ and Cs = 1; E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 50) × 0.157/√0.5 = 238.7 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 50) × 0.157/√0.5 = 288.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 6 × 6 conductors, L_C = 6 × 20 + 6 × 20 = 240 m, L_R = 4 × 3 = 12 m, L_T = 252 m, A = 400 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 6.0000 × 1.0000 = 6.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 6.000 = 1.5320, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.6592 (Eq. 86), Em = 50 × 1000 × 0.6592 × 1.5320/252 = 200.4 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4636, L_S = 0.75 × 240 + 0.85 × 12 = 190.2 m, Es = 50 × 1000 × 0.4636 × 1.5320/190.2 = 186.7 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 50 × [1/252 + (1/√(20 × 400)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/400)))] = 50 × [0.003968 + 0.011180 × 1.8994] = 1.2602 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 1000 × 1.2602 = 1260.2 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 1/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 4.17 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-20x20-small-grid-4-rods) |
Example 2 — 60 × 40 m grid, 20 rods, crushed rock, 10 kA
A zone-substation grid with 20 rods and a 3000 Ω·m crushed-rock layer (Cs = 0.70): with the full 10 kA taken as grid current (no split factor) the mesh voltage still exceeds the touch limit; the step voltage passes.
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 10 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 60 × 40 m, conductors at D = 6 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; 20 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊60/6⌋ + 1 = 11; ny = ⌊40/6⌋ + 1 = 7; LC = 7 × 60 + 11 × 40 = 860 m; LR = 20 × 3 = 60 m; LT = 920 m; A = 60 × 40 = 2,400 m²; Lp = 2 × (60 + 40) = 200 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3,019.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/920 + (1/√(20 × 2,400)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/2,400)))] = 100 × [0.001087 + 0.004564 × 1.9563] = 1.0016 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 10,000 × 1.0016 = 10,016.4 V vs Etouch 921.4 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 860/200 = 8.6000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(200/(4 × √2,400)) = 1.0103; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 8.6000 × 1.0103 = 8.688 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(6²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (6 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 6 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 8.688 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(422.21) + 0.8165 × ln(0.1555)] = 0.7203 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.688 = 1.9299 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 10,000 × 0.7203 × 1.9299 / (860 + 60) = 1,511.0 V → 1,511.0 vs limit 921.4 V FAIL |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(6 + 0.5) + (1/6) × (1 − 0.58.688 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.1538 + 0.1651] = 0.4198 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 860 + 0.85 × 60 = 696.0 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 10,000 × 0.4198 × 1.9299 / 696.0 = 1,164.1 V → 1,164.1 vs limit 3,019.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 10,000 × √0.5 / 169.66 = 41.68 mm² → next standard size 50 mm² |
| Result | 1/2 checks pass → FAIL; touch 164 % and step 39 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3019.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 11 × 7 conductors, L_C = 7 × 60 + 11 × 40 = 860 m, L_R = 20 × 3 = 60 m, L_T = 920 m, A = 2400 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 8.6000 × 1.0103 = 8.688 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.688 = 1.9299, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.7203 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 10000 × 0.7203 × 1.9299/920 = 1511.0 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4198, L_S = 0.75 × 860 + 0.85 × 60 = 696 m, Es = 100 × 10000 × 0.4198 × 1.9299/696 = 1164.1 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/920 + (1/√(20 × 2400)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/2400)))] = 100 × [0.001087 + 0.004564 × 1.9563] = 1.0016 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 10000 × 1.0016 = 10016.4 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 10/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 41.68 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-60x40-grid-rods-crushed-rock) |
Example 3 — Large 100 × 80 m grid, 10 m spacing, 40 rods, 8 kA
A transmission-substation grid: 1900 m of buried conductor and a 0.15 m crushed-rock layer keep an 8 kA fault within the touch limit at 87 % utilisation.
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 8 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 100 × 80 m, conductors at D = 10 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; 40 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 2,500 Ω·m, 0.15 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊100/10⌋ + 1 = 11; ny = ⌊80/10⌋ + 1 = 9; LC = 9 × 100 + 11 × 80 = 1,780 m; LR = 40 × 3 = 120 m; LT = 1,900 m; A = 100 × 80 = 8,000 m²; Lp = 2 × (100 + 80) = 360 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/2,500) / (2 × 0.15 + 0.09) = 0.7785 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7785 × 2,500) × 0.157/√0.5 = 870.2 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7785 × 2,500) × 0.157/√0.5 = 2,814.7 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/1,900 + (1/√(20 × 8,000)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/8,000)))] = 100 × [0.000526 + 0.002500 × 1.9756] = 0.5465 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 8,000 × 0.5465 = 4,372.3 V vs Etouch 870.2 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 1,780/360 = 9.8889; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(360/(4 × √8,000)) = 1.0031; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 9.8889 × 1.0031 = 9.920 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(10²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (10 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 10 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 9.920 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(1,086.66) + 0.8165 × ln(0.1352)] = 0.8526 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.920 = 2.1121 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 8,000 × 0.8526 × 2.1121 / (1,780 + 120) = 758.2 V → 758.2 vs limit 870.2 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(10 + 0.5) + (1/10) × (1 − 0.59.920 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.0952 + 0.0996] = 0.3803 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 1,780 + 0.85 × 120 = 1,437.0 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 8,000 × 0.3803 × 2.1121 / 1,437.0 = 447.2 V → 447.2 vs limit 2,814.7 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 8,000 × √0.5 / 169.66 = 33.34 mm² → next standard size 35 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 87 % and step 16 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/2500)/(2 × 0.15 + 0.09) = 0.7785 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7785 × 2500) × 0.157/√0.5 = 870.2 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7785 × 2500) × 0.157/√0.5 = 2814.7 V (Eq. 30); grid 11 × 9 conductors, L_C = 9 × 100 + 11 × 80 = 1780 m, L_R = 40 × 3 = 120 m, L_T = 1900 m, A = 8000 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 9.8889 × 1.0031 = 9.920 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.920 = 2.1121, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.8526 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 8000 × 0.8526 × 2.1121/1900 = 758.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.3803, L_S = 0.75 × 1780 + 0.85 × 120 = 1437 m, Es = 100 × 8000 × 0.3803 × 2.1121/1437 = 447.2 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/1900 + (1/√(20 × 8000)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/8000)))] = 100 × [0.000526 + 0.002500 × 1.9756] = 0.5465 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 8000 × 0.5465 = 4372.3 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 8/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 33.34 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-100x80-large-grid-40-rods) |
Example 4 — Fine 2.5 m mesh buried 1 m, hard-drawn 8 mm copper, 70 kg
A dense mesh at 1 m depth with no rods: Kh = √2 and the no-rod Kii apply, and the 0.3 s clearing time keeps the limits high enough to pass at 91 % touch utilisation.
Given: Soil ρ = 70 Ω·m; grid current IG = 4 kA for ts = 0.3 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 25 × 15 m, conductors at D = 2.5 m spacing buried h = 1 m, 8 mm hard-drawn copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; no rods; surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊25/2.5⌋ + 1 = 11; ny = ⌊15/2.5⌋ + 1 = 7; LC = 7 × 25 + 11 × 15 = 340 m; no rods; LT = 340 m; A = 25 × 15 = 375 m²; Lp = 2 × (25 + 15) = 80 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 70/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.6969 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.6969 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.3 = 1,185.6 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.6969 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.3 = 3,882.3 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 70 × [1/340 + (1/√(20 × 375)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 1 × √(20/375)))] = 70 × [0.002941 + 0.011547 × 1.8124] = 1.6708 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 4,000 × 1.6708 = 6,683.3 V vs Etouch 1,185.6 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 340/80 = 8.5000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(80/(4 × √375)) = 1.0163; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 8.5000 × 1.0163 = 8.638 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 1) = 1.4142; Kii = 1/(2 × 8.638)2/8.638 = 0.5170; Km = (1/2π) × [ln(2.5²/(16 × 1 × 0.008) + (2.5 + 2 × 1)²/(8 × 2.5 × 0.008) − 1/(4 × 0.008)) + (0.5170/1.4142) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 8.638 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(144.14) + 0.3656 × ln(0.1565)] = 0.6832 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.638 = 1.9225 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 70 × 4,000 × 0.6832 × 1.9225 / (340) = 1,081.6 V → 1,081.6 vs limit 1,185.6 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 1) + 1/(2.5 + 1) + (1/2.5) × (1 − 0.58.638 − 2)] = (1/π) × [0.5000 + 0.2857 + 0.3960] = 0.3761 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 340 + 0.85 × 0 = 255.0 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 70 × 4,000 × 0.3761 × 1.9225 / 255.0 = 794.0 V → 794.0 vs limit 3,882.3 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | hard-drawn copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00381/°C, ρr = 1.78 µΩ·cm, K0 = 242 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,084)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00381 × 1.78)) × ln(492/282)] = 167.53 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 4,000 × √0.3 / 167.53 = 13.08 mm² → next standard size 16 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 91 % and step 20 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 70/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.6969 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.6969 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.3 = 1185.6 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.6969 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.3 = 3882.3 V (Eq. 30); grid 11 × 7 conductors, L_C = 7 × 25 + 11 × 15 = 340 m, no rods, L_T = 340 m, A = 375 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 8.5000 × 1.0163 = 8.638 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.638 = 1.9225, Kii = 0.5170, Kh = √(1 + 1) = 1.4142, Km = 0.6832 (Eq. 86), Em = 70 × 4000 × 0.6832 × 1.9225/340 = 1081.6 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.3761, L_S = 0.75 × 340 + 0.85 × 0 = 255 m, Es = 70 × 4000 × 0.3761 × 1.9225/255 = 794.0 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 70 × [1/340 + (1/√(20 × 375)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 1√(20/375)))] = 70 × [0.002941 + 0.011547 × 1.8124] = 1.6708 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 4000 × 1.6708 = 6683.3 V; grid conductor (commercial hard-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00381, ρr 1.78, K0 242, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1084 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 4/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.3 × 0.00381 × 1.78)) × ln(492/282)] = 13.08 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-25x15-fine-mesh-deep-burial) |
Example 5 — The same fine mesh assessed for a 50 kg body
The fine-mesh grid that passes at 70 kg fails at 50 kg: Cb falls from 0.157 to 0.116, cutting the tolerable voltages by 26 %, and the mesh voltage is unchanged.
Given: Soil ρ = 70 Ω·m; grid current IG = 4 kA for ts = 0.3 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 25 × 15 m, conductors at D = 2.5 m spacing buried h = 1 m, 8 mm hard-drawn copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; no rods; surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 50 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊25/2.5⌋ + 1 = 11; ny = ⌊15/2.5⌋ + 1 = 7; LC = 7 × 25 + 11 × 15 = 340 m; no rods; LT = 340 m; A = 25 × 15 = 375 m²; Lp = 2 × (25 + 15) = 80 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 70/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.6969 |
| Tolerable voltages (50 kg) | Cb = 0.116; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.6969 × 3,000) × 0.116/√0.3 = 876.0 V (Eq. 32); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.6969 × 3,000) × 0.116/√0.3 = 2,868.5 V (Eq. 29) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 70 × [1/340 + (1/√(20 × 375)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 1 × √(20/375)))] = 70 × [0.002941 + 0.011547 × 1.8124] = 1.6708 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 4,000 × 1.6708 = 6,683.3 V vs Etouch 876.0 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 340/80 = 8.5000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(80/(4 × √375)) = 1.0163; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 8.5000 × 1.0163 = 8.638 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 1) = 1.4142; Kii = 1/(2 × 8.638)2/8.638 = 0.5170; Km = (1/2π) × [ln(2.5²/(16 × 1 × 0.008) + (2.5 + 2 × 1)²/(8 × 2.5 × 0.008) − 1/(4 × 0.008)) + (0.5170/1.4142) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 8.638 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(144.14) + 0.3656 × ln(0.1565)] = 0.6832 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.638 = 1.9225 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 70 × 4,000 × 0.6832 × 1.9225 / (340) = 1,081.6 V → 1,081.6 vs limit 876.0 V FAIL |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 1) + 1/(2.5 + 1) + (1/2.5) × (1 − 0.58.638 − 2)] = (1/π) × [0.5000 + 0.2857 + 0.3960] = 0.3761 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 340 + 0.85 × 0 = 255.0 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 70 × 4,000 × 0.3761 × 1.9225 / 255.0 = 794.0 V → 794.0 vs limit 2,868.5 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | hard-drawn copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00381/°C, ρr = 1.78 µΩ·cm, K0 = 242 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,084)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00381 × 1.78)) × ln(492/282)] = 167.53 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 4,000 × √0.3 / 167.53 = 13.08 mm² → next standard size 16 mm² |
| Result | 1/2 checks pass → FAIL; touch 124 % and step 28 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 70/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.6969 (Eq. 27); E_touch50 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.6969 × 3000) × 0.116/√0.3 = 876.0 V (Eq. 32), E_step50 = (1000 + 6 × 0.6969 × 3000) × 0.116/√0.3 = 2868.5 V (Eq. 29); grid 11 × 7 conductors, L_C = 7 × 25 + 11 × 15 = 340 m, no rods, L_T = 340 m, A = 375 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 8.5000 × 1.0163 = 8.638 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.638 = 1.9225, Kii = 0.5170, Kh = √(1 + 1) = 1.4142, Km = 0.6832 (Eq. 86), Em = 70 × 4000 × 0.6832 × 1.9225/340 = 1081.6 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.3761, L_S = 0.75 × 340 + 0.85 × 0 = 255 m, Es = 70 × 4000 × 0.3761 × 1.9225/255 = 794.0 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 70 × [1/340 + (1/√(20 × 375)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 1√(20/375)))] = 70 × [0.002941 + 0.011547 × 1.8124] = 1.6708 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 4000 × 1.6708 = 6683.3 V; grid conductor (commercial hard-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00381, ρr 1.78, K0 242, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1084 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 4/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.3 × 0.00381 × 1.78)) × ln(492/282)] = 13.08 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-25x15-fine-mesh-50kg-body) |
Example 6 — Copper-clad steel grid, 2 kA for 1 s
A slow 1 s backup clearing time lowers the tolerable voltages by √2 relative to 0.5 s; the 40 % copper-clad steel conductor, exothermic-welded so Tm is its 1084 °C fusing temperature, is sized from its own IEEE 80 Table 1 constants (k = 188.8 against 281.8 for welded annealed copper), so it needs half as much again as copper would.
Given: Soil ρ = 150 Ω·m; grid current IG = 2 kA for ts = 1 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 40 × 40 m, conductors at D = 5 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm 40 % copper-clad steel with exothermic-welded joints; 10 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊40/5⌋ + 1 = 9; ny = ⌊40/5⌋ + 1 = 9; LC = 9 × 40 + 9 × 40 = 720 m; LR = 10 × 3 = 30 m; LT = 750 m; A = 40 × 40 = 1,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (40 + 40) = 160 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 150/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7052 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7052 × 3,000) × 0.157/√1 = 655.2 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7052 × 3,000) × 0.157/√1 = 2,149.8 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 150 × [1/750 + (1/√(20 × 1,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/1,600)))] = 150 × [0.001333 + 0.005590 × 1.9471] = 1.8327 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 2,000 × 1.8327 = 3,665.3 V vs Etouch 655.2 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 720/160 = 9.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(160/(4 × √1,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 9.0000 × 1.0000 = 9.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(5²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (5 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 5 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 9.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(305.16) + 0.8165 × ln(0.1498)] = 0.6638 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.000 = 1.9760 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 150 × 2,000 × 0.6638 × 1.9760 / (720 + 30) = 524.7 V → 524.7 vs limit 655.2 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(5 + 0.5) + (1/5) × (1 − 0.59.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.1818 + 0.1984] = 0.4393 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 720 + 0.85 × 30 = 565.5 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 150 × 2,000 × 0.4393 × 1.9760 / 565.5 = 460.6 V → 460.6 vs limit 2,149.8 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | 40 % copper-clad steel: TCAP = 3.85 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00378/°C, ρr = 4.4 µΩ·cm, K0 = 245 °C, Tm = 1,084 °C (exothermic weld: fusing temperature), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.85 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00378 × 4.4)) × ln(1,329/285)] = 188.79 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 2,000 × √1 / 188.79 = 10.59 mm² → next standard size 16 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 80 % and step 21 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 150/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7052 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7052 × 3000) × 0.157/√1 = 655.2 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7052 × 3000) × 0.157/√1 = 2149.8 V (Eq. 30); grid 9 × 9 conductors, L_C = 9 × 40 + 9 × 40 = 720 m, L_R = 10 × 3 = 30 m, L_T = 750 m, A = 1600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 9.0000 × 1.0000 = 9.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.000 = 1.9760, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.6638 (Eq. 86), Em = 150 × 2000 × 0.6638 × 1.9760/750 = 524.7 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4393, L_S = 0.75 × 720 + 0.85 × 30 = 565.5 m, Es = 150 × 2000 × 0.4393 × 1.9760/565.5 = 460.6 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 150 × [1/750 + (1/√(20 × 1600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/1600)))] = 150 × [0.001333 + 0.005590 × 1.9471] = 1.8327 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 2000 × 1.8327 = 3665.3 V; grid conductor (40 % copper-clad steel wire, Table 1: TCAP 3.85, αr 0.00378, ρr 4.4, K0 245, Tm 1084 °C = fusing temperature, exothermic weld joint, Ta 40 °C) A = 2/√[(3.85 × 1e-4/(1 × 0.00378 × 4.4)) × ln(1329/285)] = 10.59 mm² (Eq. 37), agreeing with Eq. 41: 2 × Kf 10.45 × √1 kcmil × 0.5067 = 10.59 mm² (validation case c0036-40x40-copper-clad-steel-1s) |
Example 7 — Galvanised steel grid, 0.2 s clearing, 5000 Ω·m rock
Fast 0.2 s clearing lifts the tolerable voltages so a 4 kA fault in 300 Ω·m soil passes; the zinc-coated steel conductor has brazed joints, but the 450 °C brazed limit is above the 419 °C zinc fusing temperature, so Tm = min(450, 419) = 419 °C (k = 68.1) and it needs about four times the welded copper cross-section.
Given: Soil ρ = 300 Ω·m; grid current IG = 4 kA for ts = 0.2 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 50 × 30 m, conductors at D = 5 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm zinc-coated (galvanised) steel with brazed joints; 16 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 5,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊50/5⌋ + 1 = 11; ny = ⌊30/5⌋ + 1 = 7; LC = 7 × 50 + 11 × 30 = 680 m; LR = 16 × 3 = 48 m; LT = 728 m; A = 50 × 30 = 1,500 m²; Lp = 2 × (50 + 30) = 160 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 300/5,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7083 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7083 × 5,000) × 0.157/√0.2 = 2,215.9 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7083 × 5,000) × 0.157/√0.2 = 7,810.5 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 300 × [1/728 + (1/√(20 × 1,500)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/1,500)))] = 300 × [0.001374 + 0.005774 × 1.9454] = 3.7816 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 4,000 × 3.7816 = 15,126.6 V vs Etouch 2,215.9 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 680/160 = 8.5000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(160/(4 × √1,500)) = 1.0163; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 8.5000 × 1.0163 = 8.638 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(5²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (5 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 5 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 8.638 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(305.16) + 0.8165 × ln(0.1565)] = 0.6694 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.638 = 1.9225 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 300 × 4,000 × 0.6694 × 1.9225 / (680 + 48) = 2,121.4 V → 2,121.4 vs limit 2,215.9 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(5 + 0.5) + (1/5) × (1 − 0.58.638 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.1818 + 0.1980] = 0.4392 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 680 + 0.85 × 48 = 550.8 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 300 × 4,000 × 0.4392 × 1.9225 / 550.8 = 1,839.6 V → 1,839.6 vs limit 7,810.5 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | zinc-coated (galvanised) steel: TCAP = 3.93 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.0032/°C, ρr = 20.1 µΩ·cm, K0 = 293 °C, Tm = 419 °C (brazed joint: min(450, fusing 419) = fusing), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.93 × 10⁻⁴/(0.0032 × 20.1)) × ln(712/333)] = 68.14 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 4,000 × √0.2 / 68.14 = 26.25 mm² → next standard size 35 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 96 % and step 24 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 300/5000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7083 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7083 × 5000) × 0.157/√0.2 = 2215.9 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7083 × 5000) × 0.157/√0.2 = 7810.5 V (Eq. 30); grid 11 × 7 conductors, L_C = 7 × 50 + 11 × 30 = 680 m, L_R = 16 × 3 = 48 m, L_T = 728 m, A = 1500 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 8.5000 × 1.0163 = 8.638 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.638 = 1.9225, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.6694 (Eq. 86), Em = 300 × 4000 × 0.6694 × 1.9225/728 = 2121.4 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4392, L_S = 0.75 × 680 + 0.85 × 48 = 550.8 m, Es = 300 × 4000 × 0.4392 × 1.9225/550.8 = 1839.6 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 300 × [1/728 + (1/√(20 × 1500)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/1500)))] = 300 × [0.001374 + 0.005774 × 1.9454] = 3.7816 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 4000 × 3.7816 = 15126.6 V; grid conductor (zinc-coated steel rod, Table 1: TCAP 3.93, αr 0.0032, ρr 20.1, K0 293, Tm 419 °C = min(450 brazed joint limit, 419 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 4/√[(3.93 × 1e-4/(0.2 × 0.0032 × 20.1)) × ln(712/333)] = 26.25 mm² (Eq. 37), agreeing with Eq. 41: 4 × Kf 28.96 × √0.2 kcmil × 0.5067 = 26.25 mm² (validation case c0036-50x30-galvanised-steel-0.2s) |
Example 8 — 30 × 30 m grid, 200 Ω·m, no rods, no surface layer
A bare mesh in moderate soil with nothing to help it: both mesh and step voltages exceed the 70 kg limits.
Given: Soil ρ = 200 Ω·m; grid current IG = 2 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 30 × 30 m, conductors at D = 5 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 10 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; no rods; no surface layer; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊30/5⌋ + 1 = 7; ny = ⌊30/5⌋ + 1 = 7; LC = 7 × 30 + 7 × 30 = 420 m; no rods; LT = 420 m; A = 30 × 30 = 900 m²; Lp = 2 × (30 + 30) = 120 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | No surface layer: ρs = ρ = 200 Ω·m, so Cs = 1.0000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 200) × 0.157/√0.5 = 288.6 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 200) × 0.157/√0.5 = 488.5 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 200 × [1/420 + (1/√(20 × 900)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/900)))] = 200 × [0.002381 + 0.007454 × 1.9306] = 3.3542 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 2,000 × 3.3542 = 6,708.4 V vs Etouch 288.6 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 420/120 = 7.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(120/(4 × √900)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 7.0000 × 1.0000 = 7.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1/(2 × 7.000)2/7.000 = 0.4705; Km = (1/2π) × [ln(5²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01) + (5 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 5 × 0.01) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01)) + (0.4705/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 7.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(390.00) + 0.3841 × ln(0.1959)] = 0.8499 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 7.000 = 1.6800 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 200 × 2,000 × 0.8499 × 1.6800 / (420) = 1,359.8 V → 1,359.8 vs limit 288.6 V FAIL |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(5 + 0.5) + (1/5) × (1 − 0.57.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.1818 + 0.1938] = 0.4379 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 420 + 0.85 × 0 = 315.0 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 200 × 2,000 × 0.4379 × 1.6800 / 315.0 = 934.1 V → 934.1 vs limit 488.5 V FAIL |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 2,000 × √0.5 / 169.66 = 8.34 mm² → next standard size 10 mm² |
| Result | 0/2 checks pass → FAIL; touch 471 % and step 191 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: no surface layer so ρ_s = ρ and Cs = 1; E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 200) × 0.157/√0.5 = 288.6 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 200) × 0.157/√0.5 = 488.5 V (Eq. 30); grid 7 × 7 conductors, L_C = 7 × 30 + 7 × 30 = 420 m, no rods, L_T = 420 m, A = 900 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 7.0000 × 1.0000 = 7.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 7.000 = 1.6800, Kii = 0.4705, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.8499 (Eq. 86), Em = 200 × 2000 × 0.8499 × 1.6800/420 = 1359.8 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4379, L_S = 0.75 × 420 + 0.85 × 0 = 315 m, Es = 200 × 2000 × 0.4379 × 1.6800/315 = 934.1 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 200 × [1/420 + (1/√(20 × 900)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/900)))] = 200 × [0.002381 + 0.007454 × 1.9306] = 3.3542 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 2000 × 3.3542 = 6708.4 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 2/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 8.34 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-30x30-grid-200ohm-m-no-rods) |
Example 9 — Coarse 10 m mesh: touch voltage fails, step passes
Wide conductor spacing (only 4 × 4 conductors) drives the mesh voltage to twice the touch limit while the step voltage, with its 6×ρ allowance, still passes.
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 1 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 30 × 30 m, conductors at D = 10 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; no rods; no surface layer; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊30/10⌋ + 1 = 4; ny = ⌊30/10⌋ + 1 = 4; LC = 4 × 30 + 4 × 30 = 240 m; no rods; LT = 240 m; A = 30 × 30 = 900 m²; Lp = 2 × (30 + 30) = 120 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | No surface layer: ρs = ρ = 100 Ω·m, so Cs = 1.0000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 100) × 0.157/√0.5 = 255.3 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 100) × 0.157/√0.5 = 355.3 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/240 + (1/√(20 × 900)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/900)))] = 100 × [0.004167 + 0.007454 × 1.9306] = 1.8557 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 1,000 × 1.8557 = 1,855.7 V vs Etouch 255.3 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 240/120 = 4.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(120/(4 × √900)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 4.0000 × 1.0000 = 4.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1/(2 × 4.000)2/4.000 = 0.3536; Km = (1/2π) × [ln(10²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (10 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 10 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (0.3536/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 4.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(1,086.66) + 0.2887 × ln(0.3638)] = 1.0662 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 4.000 = 1.2360 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 1,000 × 1.0662 × 1.2360 / (240) = 549.1 V → 549.1 vs limit 255.3 V FAIL |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(10 + 0.5) + (1/10) × (1 − 0.54.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.0952 + 0.0750] = 0.3725 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 240 + 0.85 × 0 = 180.0 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 1,000 × 0.3725 × 1.2360 / 180.0 = 255.8 V → 255.8 vs limit 355.3 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 1,000 × √0.5 / 169.66 = 4.17 mm² → next standard size 6 mm² |
| Result | 1/2 checks pass → FAIL; touch 215 % and step 72 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: no surface layer so ρ_s = ρ and Cs = 1; E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 100) × 0.157/√0.5 = 255.3 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 100) × 0.157/√0.5 = 355.3 V (Eq. 30); grid 4 × 4 conductors, L_C = 4 × 30 + 4 × 30 = 240 m, no rods, L_T = 240 m, A = 900 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 4.0000 × 1.0000 = 4.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 4.000 = 1.2360, Kii = 0.3536, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 1.0662 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 1000 × 1.0662 × 1.2360/240 = 549.1 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.3725, L_S = 0.75 × 240 + 0.85 × 0 = 180 m, Es = 100 × 1000 × 0.3725 × 1.2360/180 = 255.8 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/240 + (1/√(20 × 900)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/900)))] = 100 × [0.004167 + 0.007454 × 1.9306] = 1.8557 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 1000 × 1.8557 = 1855.7 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 1/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 4.17 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-30x30-coarse-mesh-touch-fail) |
Example 10 — Rocky 1000 Ω·m site, 1 s clearing: both limits fail
High soil resistivity with no surface layer: even 3 kA produces mesh and step voltages far above the limits, so a surface layer, more conductor or faster clearing is needed.
Given: Soil ρ = 1,000 Ω·m; grid current IG = 3 kA for ts = 1 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 40 × 40 m, conductors at D = 8 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; 8 rods × 3 m (16 mm); no surface layer; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊40/8⌋ + 1 = 6; ny = ⌊40/8⌋ + 1 = 6; LC = 6 × 40 + 6 × 40 = 480 m; LR = 8 × 3 = 24 m; LT = 504 m; A = 40 × 40 = 1,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (40 + 40) = 160 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | No surface layer: ρs = ρ = 1,000 Ω·m, so Cs = 1.0000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 1,000) × 0.157/√1 = 392.5 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 1,000) × 0.157/√1 = 1,099.0 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 1,000 × [1/504 + (1/√(20 × 1,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/1,600)))] = 1,000 × [0.001984 + 0.005590 × 1.9471] = 12.8685 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 3,000 × 12.8685 = 38,605.5 V vs Etouch 392.5 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 480/160 = 6.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(160/(4 × √1,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 6.0000 × 1.0000 = 6.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(8²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (8 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 8 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 6.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(715.23) + 0.8165 × ln(0.2315)] = 0.8559 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 6.000 = 1.5320 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 1,000 × 3,000 × 0.8559 × 1.5320 / (480 + 24) = 7,805.2 V → 7,805.2 vs limit 392.5 V FAIL |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(8 + 0.5) + (1/8) × (1 − 0.56.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.1176 + 0.1172] = 0.3931 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 480 + 0.85 × 24 = 380.4 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 1,000 × 3,000 × 0.3931 × 1.5320 / 380.4 = 4,749.0 V → 4,749.0 vs limit 1,099.0 V FAIL |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 3,000 × √1 / 169.66 = 17.68 mm² → next standard size 25 mm² |
| Result | 0/2 checks pass → FAIL; touch 1,989 % and step 432 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: no surface layer so ρ_s = ρ and Cs = 1; E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 1.0000 × 1000) × 0.157/√1 = 392.5 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 1.0000 × 1000) × 0.157/√1 = 1099.0 V (Eq. 30); grid 6 × 6 conductors, L_C = 6 × 40 + 6 × 40 = 480 m, L_R = 8 × 3 = 24 m, L_T = 504 m, A = 1600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 6.0000 × 1.0000 = 6.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 6.000 = 1.5320, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.8559 (Eq. 86), Em = 1000 × 3000 × 0.8559 × 1.5320/504 = 7805.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.3931, L_S = 0.75 × 480 + 0.85 × 24 = 380.4 m, Es = 1000 × 3000 × 0.3931 × 1.5320/380.4 = 4749.0 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 1000 × [1/504 + (1/√(20 × 1600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/1600)))] = 1000 × [0.001984 + 0.005590 × 1.9471] = 12.8685 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 3000 × 12.8685 = 38605.5 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 3/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(1 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 17.68 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-40x40-rocky-1000ohm-m-both-fail) |
Example 11 — 30 % copper-clad steel with bolted joints limited to 250 °C
Table 1 constants for 30 % copper-clad steel with bolted (pressure-type) joints: Tm = min(250, 1084) = 250 °C instead of the fusing temperature, so k falls from 163.6 to 98.0 and the conductor grows from 35 to 50 mm².
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 5 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 40 × 40 m, conductors at D = 5 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm 30 % copper-clad steel with bolted / pressure-type joints; 16 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊40/5⌋ + 1 = 9; ny = ⌊40/5⌋ + 1 = 9; LC = 9 × 40 + 9 × 40 = 720 m; LR = 16 × 3 = 48 m; LT = 768 m; A = 40 × 40 = 1,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (40 + 40) = 160 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3,019.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/768 + (1/√(20 × 1,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/1,600)))] = 100 × [0.001302 + 0.005590 × 1.9471] = 1.2186 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 5,000 × 1.2186 = 6,093.2 V vs Etouch 921.4 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 720/160 = 9.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(160/(4 × √1,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 9.0000 × 1.0000 = 9.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(5²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (5 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 5 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 9.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(305.16) + 0.8165 × ln(0.1498)] = 0.6638 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.000 = 1.9760 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 5,000 × 0.6638 × 1.9760 / (720 + 48) = 853.9 V → 853.9 vs limit 921.4 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(5 + 0.5) + (1/5) × (1 − 0.59.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.1818 + 0.1984] = 0.4393 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 720 + 0.85 × 48 = 580.8 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 5,000 × 0.4393 × 1.9760 / 580.8 = 747.4 V → 747.4 vs limit 3,019.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | 30 % copper-clad steel: TCAP = 3.85 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00378/°C, ρr = 5.86 µΩ·cm, K0 = 245 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,084)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.85 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00378 × 5.86)) × ln(495/285)] = 97.96 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 5,000 × √0.5 / 97.96 = 36.09 mm² → next standard size 50 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 93 % and step 25 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3019.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 9 × 9 conductors, L_C = 9 × 40 + 9 × 40 = 720 m, L_R = 16 × 3 = 48 m, L_T = 768 m, A = 1600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 9.0000 × 1.0000 = 9.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.000 = 1.9760, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.6638 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 5000 × 0.6638 × 1.9760/768 = 853.9 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4393, L_S = 0.75 × 720 + 0.85 × 48 = 580.8 m, Es = 100 × 5000 × 0.4393 × 1.9760/580.8 = 747.4 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/768 + (1/√(20 × 1600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/1600)))] = 100 × [0.001302 + 0.005590 × 1.9471] = 1.2186 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 5000 × 1.2186 = 6093.2 V; grid conductor (30 % copper-clad steel wire, Table 1: TCAP 3.85, αr 0.00378, ρr 5.86, K0 245, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type joint limit, 1084 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 5/√[(3.85 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00378 × 5.86)) × ln(495/285)] = 36.09 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-40x40-ccs30-bolted-250c) |
Example 12 — 1020 steel grid, 4 kA for 1 s
A plain exothermic-welded 1020 steel grid conductor (10.8 % conductivity, ρr = 15.9 µΩ·cm, Tm = 1510 °C fusing): k = 123.7, so 32.3 mm² where welded annealed copper would need 14.2 mm²; the 4 m mesh with 24 rods passes touch at 92 %.
Given: Soil ρ = 150 Ω·m; grid current IG = 4 kA for ts = 1 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 50 × 50 m, conductors at D = 4 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 14 mm 1020 steel with exothermic-welded joints; 24 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊50/4⌋ + 1 = 13; ny = ⌊50/4⌋ + 1 = 13; LC = 13 × 50 + 13 × 50 = 1,300 m; LR = 24 × 3 = 72 m; LT = 1,372 m; A = 50 × 50 = 2,500 m²; Lp = 2 × (50 + 50) = 200 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 150/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7052 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7052 × 3,000) × 0.157/√1 = 655.2 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7052 × 3,000) × 0.157/√1 = 2,149.8 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 150 × [1/1,372 + (1/√(20 × 2,500)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/2,500)))] = 150 × [0.000729 + 0.004472 × 1.9572] = 1.4223 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 4,000 × 1.4223 = 5,689.0 V vs Etouch 655.2 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 1,300/200 = 13.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(200/(4 × √2,500)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 13.0000 × 1.0000 = 13.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(4²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.014) + (4 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 4 × 0.014) − 0.5/(4 × 0.014)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 13.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(189.73) + 0.8165 × ln(0.1019)] = 0.5380 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 13.000 = 2.5680 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 150 × 4,000 × 0.5380 × 2.5680 / (1,300 + 72) = 604.2 V → 604.2 vs limit 655.2 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(4 + 0.5) + (1/4) × (1 − 0.513.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.2222 + 0.2499] = 0.4686 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 1,300 + 0.85 × 72 = 1,036.2 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 150 × 4,000 × 0.4686 × 2.5680 / 1,036.2 = 696.8 V → 696.8 vs limit 2,149.8 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | 1020 steel: TCAP = 3.28 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.0016/°C, ρr = 15.9 µΩ·cm, K0 = 605 °C, Tm = 1,510 °C (exothermic weld: fusing temperature), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.28 × 10⁻⁴/(0.0016 × 15.9)) × ln(2,115/645)] = 123.74 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 4,000 × √1 / 123.74 = 32.33 mm² → next standard size 35 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 92 % and step 32 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 150/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7052 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7052 × 3000) × 0.157/√1 = 655.2 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7052 × 3000) × 0.157/√1 = 2149.8 V (Eq. 30); grid 13 × 13 conductors, L_C = 13 × 50 + 13 × 50 = 1300 m, L_R = 24 × 3 = 72 m, L_T = 1372 m, A = 2500 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 13.0000 × 1.0000 = 13.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 13.000 = 2.5680, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.5380 (Eq. 86), Em = 150 × 4000 × 0.5380 × 2.5680/1372 = 604.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4686, L_S = 0.75 × 1300 + 0.85 × 72 = 1036.2 m, Es = 150 × 4000 × 0.4686 × 2.5680/1036.2 = 696.8 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 150 × [1/1372 + (1/√(20 × 2500)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/2500)))] = 150 × [0.000729 + 0.004472 × 1.9572] = 1.4223 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 4000 × 1.4223 = 5689.0 V; grid conductor (1020 steel, Table 1: TCAP 3.28, αr 0.0016, ρr 15.9, K0 605, Tm 1510 °C = fusing temperature, exothermic weld joint, Ta 40 °C) A = 4/√[(3.28 × 1e-4/(1 × 0.0016 × 15.9)) × ln(2115/645)] = 32.33 mm² (Eq. 37), agreeing with Eq. 41: 4 × Kf 15.95 × √1 kcmil × 0.5067 = 32.33 mm² (validation case c0036-50x50-steel-1020-1s) |
Example 13 — 304 stainless steel at 20 °C ambient
The highest-resistivity Table 1 material (ρr = 72 µΩ·cm), exothermic-welded (Tm = 1400 °C fusing), with a 20 °C ambient instead of the 40 °C behind the tabulated Kf: k = 66.5 and 41.2 mm² for 5 kA in 0.3 s.
Given: Soil ρ = 80 Ω·m; grid current IG = 5 kA for ts = 0.3 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 30 × 20 m, conductors at D = 3 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12 mm 304 stainless steel with exothermic-welded joints; 8 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 2,500 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊30/3⌋ + 1 = 11; ny = ⌊20/3⌋ + 1 = 7; LC = 7 × 30 + 11 × 20 = 430 m; LR = 8 × 3 = 24 m; LT = 454 m; A = 30 × 20 = 600 m²; Lp = 2 × (30 + 20) = 100 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 80/2,500) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.6996 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.6996 × 2,500) × 0.157/√0.3 = 1,038.6 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.6996 × 2,500) × 0.157/√0.3 = 3,294.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 80 × [1/454 + (1/√(20 × 600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/600)))] = 80 × [0.002203 + 0.009129 × 1.9163] = 1.5757 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 5,000 × 1.5757 = 7,878.6 V vs Etouch 1,038.6 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 430/100 = 8.6000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(100/(4 × √600)) = 1.0103; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 8.6000 × 1.0103 = 8.688 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(3²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.012) + (3 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 3 × 0.012) − 0.5/(4 × 0.012)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 8.688 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(138.89) + 0.8165 × ln(0.1555)] = 0.5434 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.688 = 1.9299 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 80 × 5,000 × 0.5434 × 1.9299 / (430 + 24) = 923.9 V → 923.9 vs limit 1,038.6 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(3 + 0.5) + (1/3) × (1 − 0.58.688 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.2857 + 0.3301] = 0.5143 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 430 + 0.85 × 24 = 342.9 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 80 × 5,000 × 0.5143 × 1.9299 / 342.9 = 1,157.9 V → 1,157.9 vs limit 3,294.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | 304 stainless steel: TCAP = 4.03 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.0013/°C, ρr = 72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 749 °C, Tm = 1,400 °C (exothermic weld: fusing temperature), Ta = 20 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(4.03 × 10⁻⁴/(0.0013 × 72)) × ln(2,149/769)] = 66.52 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 5,000 × √0.3 / 66.52 = 41.17 mm² → next standard size 50 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 89 % and step 35 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 80/2500)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.6996 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.6996 × 2500) × 0.157/√0.3 = 1038.6 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.6996 × 2500) × 0.157/√0.3 = 3294.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 11 × 7 conductors, L_C = 7 × 30 + 11 × 20 = 430 m, L_R = 8 × 3 = 24 m, L_T = 454 m, A = 600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 8.6000 × 1.0103 = 8.688 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 8.688 = 1.9299, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.5434 (Eq. 86), Em = 80 × 5000 × 0.5434 × 1.9299/454 = 923.9 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.5143, L_S = 0.75 × 430 + 0.85 × 24 = 342.9 m, Es = 80 × 5000 × 0.5143 × 1.9299/342.9 = 1157.9 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 80 × [1/454 + (1/√(20 × 600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/600)))] = 80 × [0.002203 + 0.009129 × 1.9163] = 1.5757 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 5000 × 1.5757 = 7878.6 V; grid conductor (304 stainless steel, Table 1: TCAP 4.03, αr 0.0013, ρr 72.0, K0 749, Tm 1400 °C = fusing temperature, exothermic weld joint, Ta 20 °C) A = 5/√[(4.03 × 1e-4/(0.3 × 0.0013 × 72.0)) × ln(2149/769)] = 41.17 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-30x20-stainless-304-ambient-20c) |
Example 14 — 40 × 40 m grid buried 2 m: depth term of Eq. 57
Burying the grid at 2 m instead of 0.5 m cuts the Eq. 57 depth factor from 1.947 to 1.817 on the area term only, so Rg falls from 1.227 to 1.155 Ω; the step voltage falls far more because Ks depends on h.
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 3 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 40 × 40 m, conductors at D = 5 m spacing buried h = 2 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; no rods; surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊40/5⌋ + 1 = 9; ny = ⌊40/5⌋ + 1 = 9; LC = 9 × 40 + 9 × 40 = 720 m; no rods; LT = 720 m; A = 40 × 40 = 1,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (40 + 40) = 160 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3,019.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/720 + (1/√(20 × 1,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 2 × √(20/1,600)))] = 100 × [0.001389 + 0.005590 × 1.8173] = 1.1548 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 3,000 × 1.1548 = 3,464.3 V vs Etouch 921.4 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 720/160 = 9.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(160/(4 × √1,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 9.0000 × 1.0000 = 9.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 2) = 1.7321; Kii = 1/(2 × 9.000)2/9.000 = 0.5261; Km = (1/2π) × [ln(5²/(16 × 2 × 0.01278) + (5 + 2 × 2)²/(8 × 5 × 0.01278) − 2/(4 × 0.01278)) + (0.5261/1.7321) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 9.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(180.46) + 0.3037 × ln(0.1498)] = 0.7351 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.000 = 1.9760 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 3,000 × 0.7351 × 1.9760 / (720) = 605.2 V → 605.2 vs limit 921.4 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 2) + 1/(5 + 2) + (1/5) × (1 − 0.59.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [0.2500 + 0.1429 + 0.1984] = 0.1882 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 720 + 0.85 × 0 = 540.0 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 3,000 × 0.1882 × 1.9760 / 540.0 = 206.6 V → 206.6 vs limit 3,019.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 3,000 × √0.5 / 169.66 = 12.50 mm² → next standard size 16 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 66 % and step 7 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3019.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 9 × 9 conductors, L_C = 9 × 40 + 9 × 40 = 720 m, no rods, L_T = 720 m, A = 1600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 9.0000 × 1.0000 = 9.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 9.000 = 1.9760, Kii = 0.5261, Kh = √(1 + 2) = 1.7321, Km = 0.7351 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 3000 × 0.7351 × 1.9760/720 = 605.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.1882, L_S = 0.75 × 720 + 0.85 × 0 = 540 m, Es = 100 × 3000 × 0.1882 × 1.9760/540 = 206.6 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/720 + (1/√(20 × 1600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 2√(20/1600)))] = 100 × [0.001389 + 0.005590 × 1.8173] = 1.1548 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 3000 × 1.1548 = 3464.3 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type (default) joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 3/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 12.50 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-40x40-burial-2m-grid-resistance) |
Example 15 — Joint type: exothermic-welded annealed copper, 10 kA for 0.5 s
Exothermic welds fuse with the conductor, so Tm is annealed copper's 1083 °C fusing temperature (IEEE 80 Table 1): k = 281.8 and 25.09 mm² → 35 mm². The grid itself passes touch at 86 %.
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 10 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 60 × 60 m, conductors at D = 4 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with exothermic-welded joints; 24 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; ny = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; LC = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1,920 m; LR = 24 × 3 = 72 m; LT = 1,992 m; A = 60 × 60 = 3,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (60 + 60) = 240 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3,019.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/1,992 + (1/√(20 × 3,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/3,600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 10,000 × 0.7822 = 7,821.7 V vs Etouch 921.4 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 1,920/240 = 16.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(240/(4 × √3,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(4²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (4 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 4 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 16.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(207.84) + 0.8165 × ln(0.0821)] = 0.5246 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 10,000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120 / (1,920 + 72) = 793.2 V → 793.2 vs limit 921.4 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(4 + 0.5) + (1/4) × (1 − 0.516.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.2222 + 0.2500] = 0.4686 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 1,920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1,501.2 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 10,000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120 / 1,501.2 = 940.2 V → 940.2 vs limit 3,019.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 1,083 °C (exothermic weld: fusing temperature), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(1,317/274)] = 281.84 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 10,000 × √0.5 / 281.84 = 25.09 mm² → next standard size 35 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 86 % and step 31 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3019.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 16 × 16 conductors, L_C = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1920 m, L_R = 24 × 3 = 72 m, L_T = 1992 m, A = 3600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.5246 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 10000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120/1992 = 793.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4686, L_S = 0.75 × 1920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1501.2 m, Es = 100 × 10000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120/1501.2 = 940.2 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/1992 + (1/√(20 × 3600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/3600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 10000 × 0.7822 = 7821.7 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 1083 °C = fusing temperature, exothermic weld joint, Ta 40 °C) A = 10/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(1317/274)] = 25.09 mm² (Eq. 37), agreeing with Eq. 41: 10 × Kf 7.0 × √0.5 kcmil × 0.5067 = 25.08 mm² (validation case c0036-60x60-cu-10ka-exothermic-weld) |
Example 16 — Joint type: brazed annealed copper (450 °C), 10 kA for 0.5 s
A brazed joint limits Tm to 450 °C: ln((234 + 450)/(234 + 40)) = 0.915 against 1.570 at the fusing temperature, so k falls to 215.1 and the minimum rises to 32.87 mm², still within 35 mm².
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 10 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 60 × 60 m, conductors at D = 4 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with brazed joints; 24 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; ny = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; LC = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1,920 m; LR = 24 × 3 = 72 m; LT = 1,992 m; A = 60 × 60 = 3,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (60 + 60) = 240 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3,019.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/1,992 + (1/√(20 × 3,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/3,600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 10,000 × 0.7822 = 7,821.7 V vs Etouch 921.4 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 1,920/240 = 16.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(240/(4 × √3,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(4²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (4 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 4 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 16.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(207.84) + 0.8165 × ln(0.0821)] = 0.5246 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 10,000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120 / (1,920 + 72) = 793.2 V → 793.2 vs limit 921.4 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(4 + 0.5) + (1/4) × (1 − 0.516.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.2222 + 0.2500] = 0.4686 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 1,920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1,501.2 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 10,000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120 / 1,501.2 = 940.2 V → 940.2 vs limit 3,019.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 450 °C (brazed joint: min(450, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(684/274)] = 215.14 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 10,000 × √0.5 / 215.14 = 32.87 mm² → next standard size 35 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 86 % and step 31 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3019.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 16 × 16 conductors, L_C = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1920 m, L_R = 24 × 3 = 72 m, L_T = 1992 m, A = 3600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.5246 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 10000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120/1992 = 793.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4686, L_S = 0.75 × 1920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1501.2 m, Es = 100 × 10000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120/1501.2 = 940.2 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/1992 + (1/√(20 × 3600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/3600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 10000 × 0.7822 = 7821.7 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 450 °C = min(450 brazed joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 10/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(684/274)] = 32.87 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-60x60-cu-10ka-brazed-450c) |
Example 17 — Joint type: bolted annealed copper (250 °C), 10 kA for 0.5 s
Bolted, clamp and compression (pressure-type) connectors limit Tm to 250 °C, the default joint type: k = 169.7 and 41.68 mm² → 50 mm², one size above the welded grid.
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 10 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 60 × 60 m, conductors at D = 4 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints; 24 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; ny = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; LC = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1,920 m; LR = 24 × 3 = 72 m; LT = 1,992 m; A = 60 × 60 = 3,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (60 + 60) = 240 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3,019.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/1,992 + (1/√(20 × 3,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/3,600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 10,000 × 0.7822 = 7,821.7 V vs Etouch 921.4 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 1,920/240 = 16.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(240/(4 × √3,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(4²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (4 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 4 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 16.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(207.84) + 0.8165 × ln(0.0821)] = 0.5246 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 10,000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120 / (1,920 + 72) = 793.2 V → 793.2 vs limit 921.4 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(4 + 0.5) + (1/4) × (1 − 0.516.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.2222 + 0.2500] = 0.4686 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 1,920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1,501.2 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 10,000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120 / 1,501.2 = 940.2 V → 940.2 vs limit 3,019.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 250 °C (bolted / pressure-type joint: min(250, fusing 1,083)), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 169.66 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 10,000 × √0.5 / 169.66 = 41.68 mm² → next standard size 50 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 86 % and step 31 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3019.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 16 × 16 conductors, L_C = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1920 m, L_R = 24 × 3 = 72 m, L_T = 1992 m, A = 3600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.5246 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 10000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120/1992 = 793.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4686, L_S = 0.75 × 1920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1501.2 m, Es = 100 × 10000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120/1501.2 = 940.2 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/1992 + (1/√(20 × 3600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/3600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 10000 × 0.7822 = 7821.7 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 250 °C = min(250 bolted/pressure-type joint limit, 1083 fusing) per IEEE 80 §11.3, Ta 40 °C) A = 10/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(484/274)] = 41.68 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-60x60-cu-10ka-bolted-250c) |
Example 18 — Tm override: IEEE 837-qualified compression connectors at 350 °C
A compression connector qualified to IEEE Std 837 for 350 °C is entered as an explicit Tm override, which replaces the 250 °C bolted limit: k = 195.7 and 36.14 mm² → 50 mm².
Given: Soil ρ = 100 Ω·m; grid current IG = 10 kA for ts = 0.5 s (no Sf/Df applied). Grid 60 × 60 m, conductors at D = 4 m spacing buried h = 0.5 m, 12.78 mm annealed copper with bolted / pressure-type joints (Tm override 350 °C); 24 rods × 3 m (16 mm); surface layer 3,000 Ω·m, 0.1 m thick; body weight 70 kg.
| Geometry | nx = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; ny = ⌊60/4⌋ + 1 = 16; LC = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1,920 m; LR = 24 × 3 = 72 m; LT = 1,992 m; A = 60 × 60 = 3,600 m²; Lp = 2 × (60 + 60) = 240 m |
|---|---|
| Surface layer (Eq. 27) | Cs = 1 − 0.09 × (1 − 100/3,000) / (2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 |
| Tolerable voltages (70 kg) | Cb = 0.157; Etouch = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33); Estep = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3,000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3,019.6 V (Eq. 30) |
| Grid resistance (Eq. 57) and GPR | Rg = ρ × [1/LT + (1/√(20A)) × (1 + 1/(1 + h√(20/A)))] = 100 × [1/1,992 + (1/√(20 × 3,600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5 × √(20/3,600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω; GPR = IG × Rg = 10,000 × 0.7822 = 7,821.7 V vs Etouch 921.4 V INFO |
| Effective conductors n | na = 2LC/Lp = 2 × 1,920/240 = 16.0000; nb = √(Lp/(4√A)) = √(240/(4 × √3,600)) = 1.0000; nc = nd = 1 (rectangle); n = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 |
| Mesh factor Km (Eq. 86) | Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247; Kii = 1 (rods); Km = (1/2π) × [ln(4²/(16 × 0.5 × 0.01278) + (4 + 2 × 0.5)²/(8 × 4 × 0.01278) − 0.5/(4 × 0.01278)) + (1.0000/1.2247) × ln(8/(π × (2 × 16.000 − 1)))] = (1/2π) × [ln(207.84) + 0.8165 × ln(0.0821)] = 0.5246 |
| Irregularity factor Ki | Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120 |
| Mesh voltage Em (Eq. 85) | Em = ρ × IG × Km × Ki / (LC + LR) = 100 × 10,000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120 / (1,920 + 72) = 793.2 V → 793.2 vs limit 921.4 V PASS |
| Step factor Ks | Ks = (1/π) × [1/(2 × 0.5) + 1/(4 + 0.5) + (1/4) × (1 − 0.516.000 − 2)] = (1/π) × [1.0000 + 0.2222 + 0.2500] = 0.4686 |
| Step voltage Es | LS = 0.75 × 1,920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1,501.2 m; Es = ρ × IG × Ks × Ki / LS = 100 × 10,000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120 / 1,501.2 = 940.2 V → 940.2 vs limit 3,019.6 V PASS |
| Grid conductor (Eq. 37, Table 1) | annealed copper: TCAP = 3.42 J/(cm³·°C), αr = 0.00393/°C, ρr = 1.72 µΩ·cm, K0 = 234 °C, Tm = 350 °C (user override of the bolted / pressure-type joint limit), Ta = 40 °C; k = 1000 × √[(TCAP × 10⁻⁴/(αr × ρr)) × ln((K0 + Tm)/(K0 + Ta))] = 1000 × √[(3.42 × 10⁻⁴/(0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(584/274)] = 195.67 A·√s/mm²; A = IG × √t / k = 10,000 × √0.5 / 195.67 = 36.14 mm² → next standard size 50 mm² |
| Result | 2/2 checks pass → PASS; touch 86 % and step 31 % of tolerable; governing: touch voltage |
| Reference | Hand calculation, IEEE 80-2013: Cs = 1 − 0.09(1 − 100/3000)/(2 × 0.1 + 0.09) = 0.7000 (Eq. 27); E_touch70 = (1000 + 1.5 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 921.4 V (Eq. 33), E_step70 = (1000 + 6 × 0.7000 × 3000) × 0.157/√0.5 = 3019.6 V (Eq. 30); grid 16 × 16 conductors, L_C = 16 × 60 + 16 × 60 = 1920 m, L_R = 24 × 3 = 72 m, L_T = 1992 m, A = 3600 m²; n = n_a·n_b = 16.0000 × 1.0000 = 16.000 (§16.5.1), Ki = 0.644 + 0.148 × 16.000 = 3.0120, Kii = 1.0000, Kh = √(1 + 0.5) = 1.2247, Km = 0.5246 (Eq. 86), Em = 100 × 10000 × 0.5246 × 3.0120/1992 = 793.2 V (Eq. 85); Ks = 0.4686, L_S = 0.75 × 1920 + 0.85 × 72 = 1501.2 m, Es = 100 × 10000 × 0.4686 × 3.0120/1501.2 = 940.2 V (§16.5.2); R_g = 100 × [1/1992 + (1/√(20 × 3600)) × (1 + 1/(1 + 0.5√(20/3600)))] = 100 × [0.000502 + 0.003727 × 1.9641] = 0.7822 Ω (Eq. 57, Sverak), GPR = 10000 × 0.7822 = 7821.7 V; grid conductor (annealed soft-drawn copper, Table 1: TCAP 3.42, αr 0.00393, ρr 1.72, K0 234, Tm 350 °C = user override of the bolted/pressure-type joint limit, Ta 40 °C) A = 10/√[(3.42 × 1e-4/(0.5 × 0.00393 × 1.72)) × ln(584/274)] = 36.14 mm² (Eq. 37) (validation case c0036-60x60-cu-10ka-compression-override-350c) |
Standards & References
- IEEE Std 80-2013 — Guide for Safety in AC Substation Grounding. Primary reference for all formulas and safety criteria.
- IEEE Std 81-2012 — Guide for Measuring Earth Resistivity, Ground Impedance, and Earth Surface Potentials.
- AS 2067:2016 — Substations and high voltage installations exceeding 1 kV a.c.
- ENA EG-0:2006 — Power System Earthing Guide (Australia/NZ).
Tips & Limitations
- This calculator handles rectangular grids with uniform spacing. For L-shaped, irregular, or multi-zone grids, use the Earth Grid 3D Tool.
- Ground rods are assumed evenly distributed around the grid perimeter. In practice, rods at corners and along edges provide the most benefit.
- Crushed rock surface layers (3,000–5,000 Ω·m) dramatically increase tolerable touch and step voltages — always include one where installed.
- If mesh voltage fails, consider: reducing spacing, adding more ground rods, increasing grid area, or using deeper burial.
- Eq. 57 (Sverak) assumes uniform soil and a grid depth of 0.25 – 2.5 m. For two-layer soil, very large or irregular grids, use a numerical (segment or finite element) method.
- Soil resistivity varies significantly with moisture, temperature, and depth — use measured values from a Wenner 4-pin test where possible.
Developer Guide — Architecture
This calculator follows the standard calcs component pattern:
components/c0036_earth_grid_design/ ├── __init__.py # Docstring ├── apps.py # Django AppConfig ├── calculations.py # Pure Python — IEEE 80 formulas ported from TS ├── component.py # Schema, Calculator class, builders, registration ├── equations.py # LaTeX equation templates └── templates/.../sidebar_form.html # Vue 3 sidebar form
The IEEE 80 formulas were ported from the Vue 3 Earth Grid tool at
_vuejs/tools/earth_grid/utils/math.ts. The Python implementation uses
IEEE 80-2013 Eq. 57 (Sverak) for grid resistance (vs the full segment-based
resistance summation in the 3D tool) and Eq. 37 with the Table 1 material constants for the grid conductor.
Developer Guide — Code Paths
| Purpose | File | Key Function / Class |
|---|---|---|
| Surface derating | calculations.py | calculate_cs() |
| Grid geometry | calculations.py | calculate_grid_geometry() |
| Grid resistance | calculations.py | calculate_grid_resistance() |
| Mesh/step factors | calculations.py | calculate_km(), calculate_ks(), calculate_ki() |
| Grid conductor size | calculations.py | grid_conductor_k(), calculate_grid_conductor_size(), GRID_CONDUCTOR_MATERIALS |
| Tolerable voltages | calculations.py | calculate_tolerable_touch(), calculate_tolerable_step() |
| Main entry | calculations.py | calculate_earth_grid(data) |
| Validation | component.py | EarthGridDesignCalculator.validate_parameters() |
| Registration | component.py | register_component(registry) |
Developer Guide — Testing
# Run all tests for this component pytest calcs/test_c0036_earth_grid_design.py -v
The worked examples above are generated from the validation corpus (mcp_public/validation/cases/fe_calc_earthing/) by python manage.py generate_help_examples --tool fe_calc_earthing; regenerate after any engine change.
Test coverage includes:
TestCalculateCs— surface layer derating factorTestGridGeometry— conductor count and total lengthTestGridResistance— with and without ground rodsTestKmKsKi— IEEE 80 geometric factorsTestTolerableVoltages— touch and step voltage limitsTestSafetyAssessment— full pass/fail logicTestCalculateEarthGrid— end-to-end integrationTestCalculatorClass— validation, round-trip, registration